Buffalo Nickel Values (1913–1938)

Coin	Raw Price	Top Grade	Sales	Updated
1913-D	$61.78	$649.49	75	Aug 5, 2026
1913-P	$17.32	$290.56	177	Aug 5, 2026
1913-S	$65.86	—	66	Aug 5, 2026
1914-D	$86.35	—	23	Aug 5, 2026
1914-P	$19.40	—	57	Aug 5, 2026
1914-S	$24.10	—	43	Aug 5, 2026
1915-D	$17.86	—	28	Aug 5, 2026
1915-P	$12.24	$668.58	37	Aug 5, 2026
1915-S	$36.91	—	32	Aug 5, 2026
1916-D	$18.48	$355.00	33	Aug 5, 2026
1916-P	$16.34	$105.15	50	Aug 5, 2026
1916-S	$16.49	—	33	Aug 5, 2026
1917-D	$19.07	$710.09	39	Aug 5, 2026
1917-P	$12.78	—	33	Aug 5, 2026
1917-S	$21.52	$2,700.00	27	Aug 5, 2026
1918-D	$26.61	—	35	Aug 5, 2026
1918-P	$8.82	$535.55	43	Aug 5, 2026
1918-S	$32.71	—	35	Aug 5, 2026
1919-D	$17.40	—	41	Aug 5, 2026
1919-P	$7.54	$288.99	44	Aug 5, 2026
1919-S	$28.17	—	33	Aug 5, 2026
1920-D	$20.68	—	32	Aug 5, 2026
1920-P	$12.46	—	35	Aug 5, 2026
1920-S	$11.40	—	39	Aug 5, 2026
1921-P	$9.06	—	38	Aug 5, 2026
1921-S	$53.34	—	36	Aug 5, 2026
1923-P	$5.05	$376.46	34	Aug 5, 2026
1923-S	$6.37	$1,599.95	37	Aug 5, 2026
1924-D	$10.06	—	25	Aug 5, 2026
1924-P	$5.20	$685.00	29	Aug 5, 2026
1924-S	$29.32	—	41	Aug 5, 2026
1925-D	$13.97	—	23	Aug 5, 2026
1925-P	$6.07	—	19	Aug 5, 2026
1925-S	$16.88	—	28	Aug 5, 2026
1926-D	$15.50	$624.75	37	Aug 5, 2026
1926-P	$6.45	$255.00	36	Aug 5, 2026
1926-S	$42.20	—	26	Aug 5, 2026
1927	$7.87	$585.00	16	Aug 5, 2026
1927-D	$14.75	$892.20	25	Aug 5, 2026
1927-P	$3.88	—	13	Aug 5, 2026
1927-S	$7.07	—	24	Aug 5, 2026
1928-D	$9.73	$183.28	19	Aug 5, 2026
1928-P	$3.82	$481.10	20	Aug 5, 2026
1928-S	$7.20	—	18	Aug 5, 2026
1929-D	$9.02	—	29	Aug 5, 2026
1929-P	$9.66	$149.95	21	Aug 5, 2026
1929-S	$11.33	$459.00	29	Aug 5, 2026
1930-P	$4.87	$128.43	39	Aug 5, 2026
1930-S	$9.93	—	45	Aug 5, 2026
1931-P	—	—	—	—
1931-S	$19.15	$376.07	52	Aug 5, 2026
1934-D	$4.99	$138.03	18	Aug 5, 2026
1934-P	$3.93	$97.38	26	Aug 5, 2026
1935	$10.04	$85.00	43	Aug 5, 2026
1935-D	$3.67	$299.00	19	Aug 5, 2026
1935-P	$4.58	$64.00	20	Aug 5, 2026
1935-S	$8.48	$255.00	28	Aug 5, 2026
1936-D	$6.46	$220.17	23	Aug 5, 2026
1936-P	$7.04	$157.78	70	Aug 5, 2026
1936-S	$5.94	—	26	Aug 5, 2026
1937-D	$17.07	$79.66	62	Aug 5, 2026
1937-P	$6.96	$84.34	85	Aug 5, 2026
1937-S	$8.25	$74.63	34	Aug 5, 2026
1938-D	$28.30	$86.49	151	Aug 5, 2026

Prices are computed from real eBay sold listings tracked by CoinGrader — recent sales weighted more heavily, obvious outliers removed. Photos are from each coin's most recent tracked sale. Coins without a link don't have enough tracked sales yet.