Buffalo Nickel Values (1913–1938)

Coin	Raw Price	Top Grade	Sales	Last sale
1913-D	$61.82	$633.04	75	Jul 23, 2026
1913-P	$17.37	$284.93	177	Jul 23, 2026
1913-S	$66.24	n/a	66	Jul 23, 2026
1914-D	$85.78	n/a	23	Jul 23, 2026
1914-P	$19.58	n/a	57	Jul 23, 2026
1914-S	$24.05	n/a	43	Jul 22, 2026
1915-D	$18.12	n/a	28	Jul 23, 2026
1915-P	$12.16	$679.76	37	Jul 23, 2026
1915-S	$36.46	n/a	32	Jul 21, 2026
1916-D	$18.33	$355.00	33	Jul 23, 2026
1916-P	$16.07	$105.04	50	Jul 23, 2026
1916-S	$16.48	n/a	33	Jul 22, 2026
1917-D	$18.93	$710.09	39	Jul 22, 2026
1917-P	$12.78	n/a	33	Jul 23, 2026
1917-S	$21.50	$2,700.00	27	Jul 23, 2026
1918-D	$26.57	n/a	35	Jul 22, 2026
1918-P	$8.97	$535.55	43	Jul 23, 2026
1918-S	$32.60	n/a	35	Jul 23, 2026
1919-D	$17.47	n/a	41	Jul 23, 2026
1919-P	$7.47	$292.72	44	Jul 23, 2026
1919-S	$28.45	n/a	33	Jul 22, 2026
1920-D	$20.69	n/a	32	Jul 22, 2026
1920-P	$12.25	n/a	35	Jul 23, 2026
1920-S	$11.60	n/a	39	Jul 23, 2026
1921-P	$8.85	n/a	38	Jul 23, 2026
1921-S	$53.22	n/a	36	Jul 23, 2026
1923-P	$4.73	$375.52	34	Jul 22, 2026
1923-S	$6.54	$1,599.95	37	Jul 23, 2026
1924-D	$10.09	n/a	25	Jul 22, 2026
1924-P	$5.24	$685.00	29	Jul 23, 2026
1924-S	$29.27	n/a	41	Jul 22, 2026
1925-D	$14.07	n/a	23	Jul 23, 2026
1925-P	$6.07	n/a	19	Jul 23, 2026
1925-S	$17.03	n/a	28	Jul 23, 2026
1926-D	$15.48	$624.75	37	Jul 22, 2026
1926-P	$4.37	$255.00	36	Jul 23, 2026
1926-S	$41.99	n/a	26	Jul 22, 2026
1927-D	$15.15	$895.98	25	Jul 22, 2026
1927-P	$5.68	$585.00	29	Jul 23, 2026
1927-S	$6.98	n/a	24	Jul 21, 2026
1928-D	$9.57	$177.82	19	Jul 21, 2026
1928-P	$3.82	$491.82	20	Jul 22, 2026
1928-S	$7.16	n/a	18	Jul 21, 2026
1929-D	$8.96	n/a	29	Jul 22, 2026
1929-P	$9.58	$149.95	21	Jul 23, 2026
1929-S	$11.35	$459.00	29	Jul 22, 2026
1930-P	$4.91	$129.45	39	Jul 22, 2026
1930-S	$9.84	n/a	45	Jul 22, 2026
1931-P	n/a	n/a	0	n/a
1931-S	$19.07	$380.90	52	Jul 23, 2026
1934-D	$4.96	$138.03	18	Jul 23, 2026
1934-P	$3.95	$96.64	26	Jul 22, 2026
1935-D	$3.64	$299.00	19	Jul 21, 2026
1935-P	$9.39	$77.88	63	Jul 22, 2026
1935-S	$8.37	$255.00	28	Jul 21, 2026
1936-D	$6.40	$218.09	23	Jul 22, 2026
1936-P	$7.03	$157.09	70	Jul 23, 2026
1936-S	$5.97	n/a	26	Jul 22, 2026
1937-D	$17.14	$80.96	62	Jul 23, 2026
1937-P	$6.87	$83.96	85	Jul 23, 2026
1937-S	$8.36	$75.05	34	Jul 23, 2026
1938-D	$28.40	$87.29	152	Jul 23, 2026

Prices are calculated from eBay sold listings CoinGrader recorded, with recent sales counting more and obvious outliers removed. They are past sale prices, not live prices. Photos are from each coin's most recent recorded sale. Coins without a link have no recorded sales.