1923-P Buffalo Nickel Value
Real sold prices from 10 tracked eBay sales — tracking since July 2026.
Computed from 10 real eBay sold listings tracked by CoinGrader since Jul 2026 · prices updated Jul 14, 2026. Not price-guide estimates.
Recent sales
| Date | Grade | Price | Listing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 14, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $9.00 | 1923 Indian Head Buffalo Nickel. Nice Coin |
| Jul 13, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $4.50 | 1923 Buffalo Nickel Fine+ #1 |
| Jul 13, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $4.00 | 1923 BUFFALO NICKEL GOOD / VERY GOOD G/VG NICE ORIGINAL COIN Readable Date |
| Jul 13, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $3.23 | 1923 Buffalo Nickel |
| Jul 13, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $49.99 | 1923-P Buffalo Nickel Choice Original AU Full Horn #QA 905-114 |
| Jul 12, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $166.50 | 1923 Buffalo Nickel BU *UNCIRCULATED* MS E251 ADAPT |
| Jul 12, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $11.51 | 1923 Philadelphia Mint Buffalo Nickel |
| Jul 12, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $3.20 | 1923 Philadelphia Mint Buffalo Nickel |
| Jul 11, 2026 | ICG 65 | $379.00 | 1923-P Buffalo Nickel - ICG MS65 - #7786D |
| Jul 11, 2026 | Raw (ungraded) | $2.68 | 1923-P Buffalo Nickel - Actual Coin Shown - Free Shipping & Tracking INV#105 |
Frequently asked questions
How much is a 1923-P Buffalo Nickel worth?
Based on real eBay sold listings, a raw (ungraded) 1923-P Buffalo Nickel sells for around $3. Top-grade certified examples sell for around $379. These figures come from 10 tracked sales, not a price guide.
Where do these prices come from?
CoinGrader continuously tracks completed eBay sales for this coin. Prices shown are computed from those real transactions (recent sales weighted more heavily, obvious outliers removed) — they are market prices, not catalog or price-guide values.
Should I get my 1923-P Buffalo Nickel graded?
Top-grade examples of this coin sell for around $379 versus roughly $3 raw, so grading can pay off if your coin is high quality. You can upload photos to CoinGrader for an instant AI grade estimate before spending on certification.
Have this coin?
Grade it and track its value. Upload photos for an instant AI grade estimate and a market value based on real sales like the ones on this page.
Grade My Buffalo Nickel