1916-S Buffalo Nickel Value

Real sold prices from 13 tracked eBay sales — tracking since July 2026.

Raw (ungraded) value
$13.22
Top-grade value
—
Not enough graded sales tracked yet

Computed from 13 real eBay sold listings tracked by CoinGrader since Jul 2026 · prices updated Jul 14, 2026. Not price-guide estimates.

Recent sales

Date Grade Price Listing
Jul 14, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $19.99 1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL D-95 XF DETAILS PITTED FREE SHIPPING
Jul 14, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $24.00 1916-S Buffalo Nickel
Jul 14, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $24.96 1916-S Buffalo Nickel CHOICE VF FREE SHIPPING E210 KM
Jul 13, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $6.50 1916-S San Francisco Mint Buffalo Nickel
Jul 13, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $260.11 Uncirculated 1916-S San Francisco Mint Buffalo Nickel
Jul 13, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $75.00 1916-s Buffalo Nickel. "Prefect" XF. 194836
Jul 13, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $2.99 1916 S INDIAN HEAD "BUFFALO" NICKEL *AG - ABOUT GOOD* *FREE SHIPPING**
Jul 12, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $10.83 1916-S Buffalo Nickel Tough Date Very Fine Details Coin
Jul 11, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $14.99 1916-S BUFFALO NICKEL I-227 FREE SHIPPING
Jul 11, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $17.50 1916-S San Francisco Mint Buffalo Nickel
Jul 11, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $13.02 1916 S Buffalo Nickel - Good to Very Good Condition - 133SA
Jul 11, 2026 PCGS 53 $100.00 1916 S BUFFALO NICKEL PCGS AU53 GOLD SHIELD
Jul 11, 2026 Raw (ungraded) $9.99 1916-S Buffalo Nickel Tough Date

Frequently asked questions

How much is a 1916-S Buffalo Nickel worth?

Based on real eBay sold listings, a raw (ungraded) 1916-S Buffalo Nickel sells for around $13. These figures come from 13 tracked sales, not a price guide.

Where do these prices come from?

CoinGrader continuously tracks completed eBay sales for this coin. Prices shown are computed from those real transactions (recent sales weighted more heavily, obvious outliers removed) — they are market prices, not catalog or price-guide values.

Should I get my 1916-S Buffalo Nickel graded?

It depends on the coin's condition. You can upload photos to CoinGrader for an instant AI grade estimate and market value before spending on professional certification.

Have this coin?

Grade it and track its value. Upload photos for an instant AI grade estimate and a market value based on real sales like the ones on this page.

Grade My Buffalo Nickel

Nearby years & mints

1916-D 1916-P 1915-D 1915-P 1915-S 1917-D 1917-P 1917-S
All Buffalo Nickel values